Type to search

The two best things coming out of the victory over Denver are the avoidance of serious injuries and the individual progressions of several of the team’s young players.

Aaron Rodgers mentioned that, while not making excuses, the Pack has played three good defenses to start the season. This is true, as the Bears rank fourth in yards yielded per game, and third in points yielded (both pending Monday night’s game). Denver’s defense is tenth in yardage, and the Vikings are a respectable thirteenth.

The Eagles, meanwhile, rank 17th in yards yielded per game and 24th in points allowed. The Packers have allowed an average of 11.7 points, versus the Eagles’ 26 – a considerable margin, and one that should make the Packers a solid favorite on Thursday.

The most critical present roster concern is the receiving corps. That’s why the effort turned in by Marquez Valdes-Scantling is notable. He turned in his best overall game as a pro, with five catches for 99 yards and a touchdown. It seems no defensive back can keep up with him when he goes deep.

Another guy who registered his nearly best-ever pro game was Jamaal Williams. With Aaron Jones suffering his worst-ever stats, Jamaal stepped up with 12 carries for 59 years. He broke more tackles than I’ve ever seen before, and he justified the confidence that coach LaFleur had in calling his number. Jamaal had 113 yards, in 21 carries against Tampa Bay in his rookie year, though I hadn’t recalled that performance.

I don’t have any rankings of guard Elgton Jenkins, but he played every offensive snap, and Rodgers was not sacked and only hit the ground one time all game – so the prized rookie must have had a successful debut. For the same reason it also appears that the team’s new right guard, Billy Turner, is proving to be a fine pass protector.

Two other offensive spot players are worth a mention. It was great to see popular Danny Vitale get himself into the stats, with a 27-yard reception that was nearly a touchdown. On the downside, Geronimo Allison, who we thought had earned Rodgers’ trust during the preseason, has only seen seven balls come his way; he’s caught five, but they only added up to 24 yards, and his sole catch on Sunday was for negative yardage.

Also on the downside, Jake Kumerow is nursing a shoulder injury and was inactive on Sunday. For a guy who has had so little time on the field in his pro career, his injury history is disturbing.

Aaron Rodgers - Packers Vikings

Sep 15, 2019; Green Bay, WI, USA; Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (12) throws a pass under pressure from Minnesota Vikings defensive end Danielle Hunter (99) during the third quarter at Lambeau Field. Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

Passing Production Possibilities

Where is Green Bay’s pass production going to come from, other than from Davante? Based on what others are doing, this team needs, first, to pick up the tight end production. The league’s top five most productive TEs have from 221 to 284 yards of production after three games, and each has caught at least 16 passes. The man at the top is the Chiefs’ Travis Kelce, with 17 catches for 284 yards.

The Packers’ TE duties have been shared by Jimmy Graham, Marcedes Lewis, and Bob Tonyan, who’ve produced 30, 33, and 32 yards respectively. That’s less than 100 total yards accumulated by the group. My feeling is that this trio is at least of average as to their receiving capabilities.

It seems the Packers simply don’t fully involve their TEs as receivers – McCarthy didn’t do it, and LaFleur hasn’t either. That’s not the only problem, however. On Sunday, Rodgers twice threw over the head of an open Bob Tonyan in the game’s first ten minutes – one should have been a 43-yard touchdown throw. Tonyan has been doing his job, but it takes two to complete a pass.

Other than for Jimmy Graham, I don’t know that Rodgers lacks trust in his tight ends, but the fact remains he’s only targeted them 16 times, and only half of those have resulted in completions. Unless Graham has a productive game against Philadelphia, that could be his final game as a Green Bay starter. Yes, it’s time to panic.

The receiving yardage by the Pack’s running backs isn’t much better. Jamaal Williams has been targeted eight times and caught seven for 55 yards; Aaron Jones has also been targeted eight times and caught six, but for only 38 yards. These would be fine single-game numbers, but lousy totals three weeks into the season.

In comparison, the five most productive RBs in the league have accounted for from 12 to 20 catches, for from 115 to just over 200 yards. They include big names Alvin Kamara (NO), Christian McCaffrey (CAR) and Le‘Veon Bell (NYJ), though the name at the top is the Chargers’ Austin Ekeler, who’s caught 19 for 208 yards.

Both Aaron Jones and Jamaal Williams are fine pass catchers. Running backs don’t really need to be great route runners – they mostly just drift out into empty space. The Packers need to work harder on setting up their screens and sneaking their backs downfield.

You don’t have to look further than to Denver, who got the annoying little runner Phillip Lindsay open for four of five catches for 49 yards. For the most part, running back receiving success is due to good timing, adept faking, and creative play calling, as opposed to great individual ability.

The Packers have the personnel to produce another 40 or 50 yards a game from their running backs – they just need to nail down their timing and execution – and then call more pass plays to the running backs. I’d lay some of the blame here on offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett.

Looking Ahead

Green Bay faces Dallas in Week 5, Kansas City in Week 8, and the 49ers in Week 10 – all are on the road, and the Packers can’t be expected to win any of them if their passing game doesn’t steadily and quickly improve.

It’s great that the Packers are at +6 in turnovers – which largely explains the Packers’ perfect record. It would be foolish, however, to think this pattern will hold up game after game.

In addition to these games, the other games shaping up as the next most difficult are the pair against the Lions, in Weeks 7 and 16. Detroit, who escaped from Philadelphia on Sunday with a 27-24 win, now stands at 2-0-1.

It’s early, but it doesn’t appear that either the Bears’ Mitchell Trubisky or the Vikings’ Kirk Cousins are plaing well enough to win the division. Currently, the best quarterback in the NFC North is the Lions’ Matthew Stafford; his passer rating of 97.5 is one point ahead of Aaron’s.

Rob Born

Smart drafters don’t select the best available players, they fill a team’s positions of greatest need.



  1. Howard September 24, 2019

    Rob, I would not put the so called overthrow to Tonyan on a potential 43 yard TD onto Rodgers. Tonyan clearly slowed down on his route. It was a perfect placed ball from Rodgers if Tonyan had kept running throughout the route.

  2. Robster September 24, 2019

    In multiple reviews and angles of the near-TD pass to Tonyan, my eyes saw Tonyan run a semi-stop-and-go, and when he took off deep it took him a moment to disengage himself with his right arm from the defender, all of which happened before the throw. The last 20 yards of the route looked full sprint to me, and he separated by two yards. A decent throw and Tonyan would have at least gotten a hand on the ball. The first nine of Aaron’s throws featured five nice completions, for an impressive 109 yards. The other four were: a drop over the Middle by Allison, the overthrow to Tonyan on the right sideline, the near TD to Tonyan and another pass over the middle that was high and a bit behind Geronimo despite him being well in front and clear of the defender – Allison could not haul in the 50/50 throw. All nine pass plays featured wide-open receivers and little or no pressure on the QB. For the second straight game, the Pack started out with great play calls, protection, and execution, other than the one drop and three errant too-high throws. Truth is, In his better years, Aaron would have gone 8 for 9, for close to 200 yards.

    1. Howard September 24, 2019

      Tonyan to me slowed down. Agree there was hand fighting. As you know, hand fighting between receivers and DBs occurs on almost every pass play. Tonyan should have disengaged quicker, right/soon after he came out of his break. Rodgers made the decision to throw that ball when Tonyan was at about the 26 or 25 yard line. It took Tonyan another 3 to 5 yards to disengage after Rodgers threw the ball.
      In fairness to Tonyan, he was probably the 3rd or 4th option on the pass attempt. Adams was #1, short to the right, Lewis was #2 short to the middle, Tonyan’s clock was probably saying the ball is already out when he slowed down and looked. The line gave Rodgers extra time that allowed the throw to Tonyan to occur.
      Just my opinion.
      I will leave it up to others to discuss what must be done about Rodgers. ;-)

      1. Kato September 24, 2019

        I tend to agree with Howard, definitely appeared as if Tonyan slowed down on his route and kind of gave up on the play because he wasn’t expecting the ball. I have been pretty critical of Rodgers the past few years, but I feel that throw was pretty much on the money if Tonyan kept running

    2. Deepsky September 24, 2019

      Tonyan has a 4.58 40 time. That was about Jimmy Graham’s 40 time when he was drafted, which, of course, Graham isn’t close to that now. Tonyan needs to work with the first team offense so that these plays are more successful.

  3. Ferris September 24, 2019

    The offense is still in a cocoon and they are 3-0. If anyone offered a 3-1 start for the first quarter of the season, everyone in the Green Bay building would have taken it. Now they sit at 3-0 with a chance for 4-0…house money for the first 4 games. Now just keep the foot on the pedal and win the next game. Don’t let the Eagles steal one especially on this home-stand and with games at Dallas and at KC coming up. Those Cowboys fans are thinking don’t let Aaron Rodgers tear our hearts out with a rusty spoon….again.