• Articles
  • News
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Website Terms of Use
  • Contact
Total Packers - Green Bay Packers Blogs and News
  • Home
  • Analysis
  • Packers News
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Analysis
  • Packers News
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
No Result
View All Result
Total Packers
No Result
View All Result

Would a Video Referee Be Useful in Football?

Ed Rooney by Ed Rooney
August 21, 2019
in Articles & Analysis
4

Last year, the Cleveland Browns sort-of got an NFL referee fired over a missed false start in a game they played against the Chargers. About a month earlier, Packers coach Mike McCarthy freaked out and screamed at the referees after Clay Matthews was flagged for roughing a passer on a call that’s considered by most to be questionable at best. These were not the first – and probably not the last – cases when the decisions of the referees were questioned. While in the case of Matthews there is more than meets the eye – what most fans and McCarthy didn’t see as a foul may count as one under the rules – there are enough cases when the cameras see one thing, the public sees another, and the referees seem to see something completely different. And not only in football – similar things happen in pretty much any team sport when certain decisions have to be made based on what the referee sees. One solution to these questionable cases comes from soccer, one of the most followed sports in the world. It is called the video assistant referee or VAR for short.

Mike McCarthy argues with NFL referee
Dec 3, 2015; Detroit, MI, USA; Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy talks to a referee and points during the fourth quarter against the Detroit Lions at Ford Field. Packers win 27-23. Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports

What is a VAR?

Considering that the fate of even the highest-profile soccer matches – those at the FIFA World Cup, capable of bringing fame and a small fortune to the winner – can be decided by a single goal, the decisions of the referee (especially when it comes to free kicks, penalties, and such) are vital. Referees are only human, though, and as such, they are incapable of being in every corner of the playfield to see everything. To help them avoid making mistakes that can cost soccer teams goals and maybe even titles, the Royal Netherlands Football Association (KNVB) implemented a program called “Refereeing 2.0”, which resulted in the creation of the first video assistant referee (VAR).

The system was tested during the matches of the Dutch First Division in the 2012-2013 season, and in the following year, the KNVB proposed it to the International Football Association Board, the highest governing body in soccer that decides the rules of the game. While the system did have its opponents, the IFAB approved the trials and wrote it into the Rules of the Game last year. The VAR operates under the “minimal interference, maximum benefit” principle, and is meant to provide a way to correct “clear and obvious errors” and “serious missed incidents”.

How does the VAR work?

The VAR can be used in the case of four types of decisions: Goal/No Goal, Penalty/No Penalty, direct red card (when the player is sent off the field after committing a foul) and mistaken identity of the player being shown a red or yellow card. When one of these four decisions are taken by the referee, the VAR team reviews the recordings of every incident that falls into these categories. If no mistake is identified, it is communicated to the referee. If, in turn, the recordings don’t agree with the referee’s decision, it can be overturned automatically or the game can be stopped until a more detailed review of the incident is completed.

The first major international tournament where the VAR was used in full (at every match and every venue) was the 2018 FIFA World Cup, where a total of 335 incidents were reviewed and 14 referee decisions were overturned. The system was credited with helping last year’s World Cup become the cleanest event since 1986.

Would a similar system be beneficial to the NFL? Could it make the games “cleaner”?

Tags: Cleveland BrownsFIFA World CupKirk CousinsMike McCarthypenaltiesSan Diego ChargersVARvideo assistant referee
Previous Post

A Preview to the 2019 Season for the Green Bay Packers

Next Post

Good News: Bears Are a Play-It-Safe Team Too

Rodgers touchdown celebration

Four Interceptions Just Enough to Beat Browns 24-22

December 26, 2021
Previewing the 2021 NFL season for the Green Bay Packers

Game Day: Cleveland Browns Visit Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field

December 25, 2021
Cowboys Coach Mike McCarthy press conference

Players Are Fleeing Mike McCarthy’s Cowboys

April 1, 2020
DB Coach Jerry Gray

Packers News: Alvis Whitted Fired As WR Coach, Jerry Gray New DB Coach

January 31, 2020
Next Post
Geronimo Allison - Packers Lambeau Field

Good News: Bears Are a Play-It-Safe Team Too

Comments 4

  1. Avatar for MJ MJ says:
    4 years ago

    Considering that, in general, pro sports have become more competitive, and especially in a league as the NFL which tends to enforce parity, the entire outcome of a game may come to a single call going one way or another.

    That goes against what pro players and coaches say, along the lines of “next time we should not put the game in the referee hands”, as if it were a matter of trying hard enough. It’s the correct thing to say, not to sound butthurt. But guess what, the other team is also trying hard, and the net force in the resulting tug-of-war is rather close to zero, so, yes, a botched call can and will decide a game.

    Having the proper call made can eliminate frustrations by preventing the refs to screw up big time.

    • Avatar for MJ MJ says:
      4 years ago

      *the refs from screwing up big time.
      Tweaking sentences only to leave them worse…

  2. Avatar for thomaslind949yahoocom thomaslind949yahoocom says:
    4 years ago

    It would have been nice to have them say how it would possibly work in the NFL.

    • Avatar for MJ MJ says:
      4 years ago

      Easier to implement than in soccer, which is predicated on keeping the flow of the game. Football is already play-by-play, start-stop action. Having a small crew, even not on site, monitoring all the camera feeds, can immediately contact the refs should a wrong call be made. Doesn’t even need significantly more stoppage time as there currently is.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Total Packers - Green Bay Packers News and Rumors

Subscribe to Packers News Updates

100% Spam Free - Unsubscribe at any time.

Find It!

No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • Packer Draft Needs: Safety
  • An Aaron Rodgers Farewell
  • Packer Draft Needs: Edge
  • Inside the Packers’ Insane Ticket Situation
  • Ways to fix the Packers in 2023: Can They Win the Super Bowl?
  • Packer Draft Needs: Defensive Line
  • The ‘Will He, Won’t He’ Aaron Rodgers Debate is back
  • Can the Packers Learn From This Super Bowl?
  • Packers Season Recap: Best NFL Highlights from Green Bay
  • Comparing The 2022 First Round Wide Receivers with Christian Watson and Romeo Doubs
  • Look Into the Top 5 Favorites of This Season’s 2023 Super Bowl
  • Reviewing Gutekunst, the Packers Roster and Coaches: Where Did it All Go Wrong: The Preseason Decisions

Popular Tags

A.J. Hawk Aaron Rodgers Brett Favre Brian Gutekunst Bryan Bulaga Charles Woodson Chicago Bears Chicago Bears Clay Matthews Clay Matthews III Dallas Cowboys Davante Adams Detroit Lions Eddie Lacy fans Featured free agents game analysis Green Bay Packers Green Bay Packers Greg Jennings injuries Jay Cutler Jermichael Finley Jordy Nelson Julius Peppers Mike McCarthy Mike McCarthy Minnesota Vikings Morgan Burnett New England Patriots New Orleans Saints NFL Oakland Raiders Philadelphia Eagles predictions Randall Cobb Sam Shields San Francisco 49ers Seattle Seahawks T.J. Lang Ted Thompson Ted Thompson Tramon Williams Ty Montgomery
No Result
View All Result
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Articles
  • News
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Website Terms of Use
  • Contact

© 2022 Total Packers -- This site is not affiliated with the Green Bay Packers or Packers.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Analysis
  • Packers News
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer

© 2022 Total Packers -- This site is not affiliated with the Green Bay Packers or Packers.com