Type to search

So there’s a story from Sports Illustrated that kind of makes me want to puke. I won’t speak for our readers, but we’ve all felt that the Green Bay Packers have become a pretty dysfunctional unit. Not more apparent than now.

There’s the Mike McCarthy’s offense is stale narrative. Entirely possible. There’s the Aaron Rodgers is fucking things up to sabotage McCarthy narrative. Maybe. There’s the Ted Thompson drafted for shit for some time narrative. Likely.

So here’s the thing.

Thompson: how many times have we said you can’t rely on draft-and-develop if you draft for shit?


McCarthy: how many times have we called him Buffoon, Gravy Head or Gravy Fart?

More times than some of you have liked.

Rodgers: have always called him out when he isn’t playing well, but haven’t really heard anything like this. Tanking to get McCarthy fired?

Didn’t give any credence to the notion at first, but we’ll just give you some of the more damning insinuations from the aforementioned story.

… because Rodgers is so intelligent and such a good improvisational player, the quarterback has the green light to change plays on the field as he see fit. He does, so often that it can be hard for McCarthy to get into a rhythm as the play caller. McCarthy might call the same play three times in a game, without the play actually being run as he called it. And if McCarthy calls a play that Rodgers doesn’t like early in the game, that can sour the mood for the rest of the game. Several sources familiar with the inner workings of the organization say that it devolved into a competition over who can call the better play, and both want the credit when things go right.

Okay. I mean, I know Rodgers called that run play in Los Angeles when Aaron Jones ran for that touchdown.

Just based on pure logic. McCarthy sure as shit wasn’t calling a run play there.


Monday Night Football analyst Booger McFarland here.

McFarland says he sensed something was off (during their production meeting): “Maybe it’s their personalities, but to me, I find it very (unusual) that you get two people who really enjoy working together and enjoy being around each other, but you can’t sense or see that. I didn’t sense that from either Aaron or coach.”

As we expected…

And it isn’t if Rodgers is wrong. Maybe sometimes he is, but it now appears Rodgers doesn’t discuss play calls with McCarthy. He discusses them with his backups at times. Third-stringer Tim Boyle was the one guy who chimed in on this story and here’s what he had to say. And if McCarthy is the coach next year, this guy is getting cut.

Because Rodgers has so much freedom, McCarthy’s frustration often comes from not knowing what check his quarterback went to and why. (DeShone) Kizer and Boyle have typically been in more conversations with Rodgers throughout the week, and sometimes explain his decisions to McCarthy in order to better set up future play calls. Early in the fourth quarter in Detroit this season, the Packers’ offense was running no huddle. Rodgers and Kizer had a few conversations on the sideline before the series about wanting to create matchup issues with Lions cornerback Darius Slay, bringing Adams inside, rather than lining him up outside. The QBs decided on a series of three playcalls focused on Adams, having him run crossers or sit down in the flat to eventually set up an out route that resulted in a red-zone touchdown. McCarthy wasn’t part of those conversations, so the quarterbacks explained that series to him afterward.

Inmates running the asylum.

I mean, that’s exactly what that is.

And look, part of that is on Rodgers. Most of it is on McCarthy.

If you have an Aaron Rodgers, you have to have a coach who can coach an Aaron Rodgers. A GM that can surround an Aaron Rodgers with some talent, which it appears the Packers now have.

But maybe someone who can get an Aaron Rodgers in line. And that comes with respect.

There doesn’t appear to be much, if any, in this relationship between Aaron Rodgers and Mike McCarthy right now.

Mordecai Jones

Mordecai is a writer living in Los Angeles. He primarily writes screenplays, but also does crap like this because GREEN BAY PACKERS, baby!



  1. PF4L November 30, 2018

    Thompson: how many times have we said ……”

    I haven’t read you saying that, and what is this “we” shit again?

    Want to know who has often said you can’t drat and develop if you draft for shit?

    Correct, not you.

  2. Ferris December 1, 2018

    We have heard Rodgers is tanking to get McCarthy fired….from me! And he is.

  3. Ghost of John Jefferson December 1, 2018

    oh what bullshit. the biggest stat hound in history “tanking” to get a coach fired? bullshit. rodgers cares about his STATS and that is it.

  4. Larry December 1, 2018

    The most likely answer is usually the obvious one. 2 moves were made before the season that predicted this outcome. First, Rogers was pissed off McCarthy made zero effort to keep his QB coach with whom Rogers liked. Second was cutting Rogers best friend on the team. One could argue McCarthy did nothing to stop Gute from cutting Jordy. We all see the frustration with Rogers when he goes into sand lot mode. He and Nelson had a weird mind link connection for when Rogers was running out of the pocket and it was scramble drill time. None of the new guys have a clue. It just seems Rogers heart was never into this season. Then when you add the fundamental problems into this offense, all of which are on the HC, it has become the perfect storm for dysfunction.

    1. Donald Welsh December 1, 2018

      Flat Dick Murphy, No Stones McCarthy, Uncle Teddy, and our hero AR all share some responsibility! Maybe Gute can clean up this mess. Afterall Flatdick needs a fall guy if a new coach is named. So maybe he gives Gute a crack at finding one, if it don’t work out Flatdick has an excuse.

    2. Ferris December 1, 2018

      It’s RoDgers Larry. With a D. One time OK, 6 times…questionable.

    3. Kato December 2, 2018

      Jordy Nelson wasnt playing forever. Going sandlot mode isnt a reliable way to win in the NFL. Particularly against good disciplined defenses