Type to search

Brett Favre Hall of Fame Debate Lasted Six or Nine Seconds

Brett Favre

We all knew former Green Bay Packers quarterback Brett Favre was a shoo-in, first-ballot Pro Football Hall of Famer.

Just how much of a shoo-in was he?

Each candidate is presented to the selection committee by a local journalist who covered that player and then debate ensues. Favre didn’t really have to be presented at all and there was obviously no debate about his election.

Depending on who you ask, the whole process lasted either six or nine seconds.

Favre’s election was a no-brainer, as it should have been.

We’re not going to go through the list of accomplishments because, as a Packers fan, you’re well aware of the list of accomplishments.

Favre was presented by the Green Bay Press-Gazette’s Pete Dougherty, who gave this account of his presentation.

In talking about another candidate, (Jason) Cole said he’d consulted 199 NFL people at the Senior Bowl and asked them to pick the five players they’d put in the Hall from the list of 15 modern-day candidates. All 199 picked Favre.

So when Favre’s turn came in the meeting, I told the committee I had a presentation ready but let’s just skip it and go with what Jason Cole said. David Baker, the Hall’s president and executive director, said, “I take it that’s the final word?” I said yes, the committee cheered and we moved on to Kurt Warner.

It isn’t likely that this has happened with many Hall of Fame candidates before and it’s unlikely that it will happen with many in the future.

There aren’t many guys who have or will put together a career on par with Brett Favre’s though.

Joseph Bonham

Joseph is a fiction writer when he isn't doing this. In his spare time he likes to do manly things like drink beer and procreate.



  1. Skinny February 12, 2016

    If Dick Stanfel is in, how the hell is Jerry Kramer not? That makes no sense to me, no way in hell Stanfel was a better guard than Kramer?

  2. RelampagoBlanco February 12, 2016

    Peyton Manning should receive the same treatment seeing that he has broken most of Favre’s records.

  3. Cheese February 12, 2016

    6 seconds, what took them so long?