Type to search

Brandon Bostick has a Theory on Why Packers Cut Him

Brandon Bostick

MMQB let former Green Bay Packers tight end and onside kick botcher Brandon Bostick write a column about botching said kick, and that’s great. Less space devoted to fat man Peter King’s bloated ramblings and things he thinks he thinks about caramel macchiatos and the fucking Radisson in Indianapolis.

The gist of Bostick’s piece is this — I messed up and I’m sorry.

We know and good. Apology accepted.

Beyond that, Bostick also reveals that he’s gotten death threats. The Twitter kind, not the kind where Paul Kersey holds a Wildey against your temple and threatens to pull the trigger.

But hey, that stuff is par for the course. If you don’t want idiots to say nasty things about you, stay the hell off the Internet.

The one part of this column I did find interesting is when Bostick talks about getting the call. The one where he was informed he’d been released.

I was close to accepting my mistake, and learning to accept my new reality, when my phone rang on the morning of Feb. 16. I had just woken up and didn’t recognize the number. The caller said he was with the Packers organization, and immediately I understood: I was getting cut.

I was surprised. Yes, I was very surprised. I played in 13 games and had a pretty good season, but more importantly, I knew I was improving. But they said they have their guys, and that I didn’t develop as fast as they had hoped. They said the onside kick had something to do with it, but that’s all they said.

I feel as if there’s a little more to it than that. With how close we were to reaching the Super Bowl, I think a lot of people in the organization couldn’t live with me being there. I think seeing me would remind them of losing the NFC championship. I think the Packers wanted a new start, so I got one, too.

First, the fact that Bostick wasn’t able to name the person that called him tells us it wasn’t Mike McCarthy or Ted Thompson. I guess that’s why they have lackeys — to make calls like this.

Then again, there’s plenty of evidence that McCarthy and Thompson didn’t think much of Bostick to begin with. So, not all that surprising, although we have to wonder if A.J. Hawk got the same sort of impersonal call…

Second, “I played in 13 games and had a pretty good season.”

Mmmmmm… no.

Two catches for three yards is not a good season by any standard. In fact, on a team where all of the tight ends are average or below average and playing time is readily available for the taking, as is the case with the Packers, it’s a downright horrible season.

Third, and most importantly, Bostick thinks people didn’t want to see him because he would remind them of their colossal failure. There’s probably some truth to that. It’s also a probably a good idea to get rid of people who contributed to failure as great as the one we’re talking about.

That being said, the Packers aren’t cutting Aaron Rodgers, Clay Matthews, Morgan Burnett or Ha Ha Clinton-Dix and they contributed to the NFC Championship game failure in equal or greater proportions than Bostick did.

That brings us back to what we’ve been hearing about Bostick for a while now.

Unaccountable. Selfish. Doesn’t get it.

He’ll make a perfect Viking.

Monty McMahon

Monty McMahon is one of the founders of Total Packers. He is probably the most famous graduate of UW-Oshkosh next to Jim Gantner.



  1. Sean February 26, 2015

    Let’s see… perhaps you were cut because your mistake was one you did when you were EXPLICITLY told by the ST coach not to field the ball if your name wasn’t Hyde or Nelson. Your mistake forced McCarthy to cut his friend Slocum.

    If Nelson fields that ball.. you play in Superbowl and if you won, Slocum probably keeps his job.

    So yeah… you might have pissed off a couple of people in the building.

    But, I suspect this was a pattern of “not listening” that really got you canned.

    1. pf4l February 26, 2015


      I re-watched the video of the onside kick. One thing stood out, and that was at the point of the kick, the blockers in line with him, ran up the field. Bostick NEVER moved, he stayed there and set his feet to catch the ball, he had premeditated catching that ball.

      At first i felt a little sorry for him when he owned the mistake, but now, it’s hard to look at it as a mistake, it looks like that was his plan. Maybe to be the hero or something.

      Good riddance.

  2. Richard February 26, 2015

    Apparently “not listening”, and generally “not having a clue” contributed. I guess he can tell himself whatever he wants to help himself sleep better, no matter how misguided he might be

  3. the real russ letlow February 26, 2015

    “pretty good season” – I don’t know what his criteria are, but obviously his standards are very low. The dumb-dumb ST play is enough to ruin a season 10 times of the one he had. I believe that he is training camp fodder, because if you are waaaaay down the depth chart you better be able to play ST. and, well, you know.

  4. Howard February 26, 2015

    Bostick who? What caught my attention about the article was the fifth paragraph.” If you don’t want idiots to say nasty things about you, stay the hell off the internet.” Was that meant for a specific group of idiots?:)

  5. B Rad February 26, 2015

    Excellent Death Wish reference.

  6. Shawn Neuser February 26, 2015

    Yes, props for the Death Wish allusion.

    Really, getting death threats on the internet is fricking nothing.
    Just go online once and say something strong in either direction about guns. Seriously, it doesn’t matter which direction you go.

    You could tweet- “All gun owners are bible-thumping, impudent, rednecks who need a gun to make up for having no penis.”

    OR you could tweet- “Gun control freaks are tree-hugging fags who need the government to protect them.”

    Tweet either and you’ll get death threats… guaranteed.

  7. Salazar February 26, 2015

    And then, just like that, all the good will he earned by stepping up and taking the blame for the onside kick just disappeared. What a moron.

  8. Kyle Orton's Neckbeard February 26, 2015

    You have to pretty stupid to have mental limitations to the extent that it comprimise a your ability to play football.

    I have a theory, as in too stupid to learn the playbook got you cut more than anything else.

  9. Makayla February 27, 2015

    I’m really getting tired of him. I’m probably one of the few Packer fans that don’t feel sorry for him. He was going to get cut anyway, regardless of his mistake…..Atleast that’s how I feel. I remember he posted something about some sob story about some lady on his twitter to gain sympathy votes. I felt sorry for the lady but I don’t know why he was trying to use that story to his benefit. Byeeee Bostick. I know I sound like a horrible person but whatever. Enjoy playing for the Vaqueens.

  10. Feck February 27, 2015

    I like to believe he was right on the bubble till he tweeted about passing out drunk in an Uber, costing himself $500 less than two weeks after the Superbowl. It probably isn’t true, but it makes the story even better.

  11. theRealChuckyWasCecil February 27, 2015