Type to search

Hey Guys, Remember When the Packers Drafted All Defense?

The year was 2012 and the Green Bay Packers were coming off a 15-1 2011 season that saw them field, at the time, the worst pass defense in NFL history and lose their first playoff game to the New York Giants (at home in the divisional round).

So naturally, the Packers sat out free agency — because free agency is for chumps! — and pinned all their hopes for improvement on guys already on the team and a draft class that was almost all defenders.

Ted Thompson decided the way to fix the defense was to draft defensive players with his first six picks. The only offensive players the Packers drafted were a pair of seventh rounders — tackle Andrew Datko and quarterback B.J. Coleman.

So did that defense get any better?

Yeah, a little bit, but it sure as hell wasn’t because of the draft class. Only one of Big Ted’s picks from that haul did anything to make a difference in his rookie season. That was second-round pick Casey Hayward, who had six interceptions.

The only other guy who’s made an impression since then is fourth-round pick Mike Daniels, who had 6.5 sacks last year.

Now that the Packers have shipped another non-achiever out of town in the form of Jerel Worthy, that draft looks a lot like this.

Packers 2012 draft

Let’s review.

1. Nick Perry — Has missed almost as many games because of injury (15) as he’s been healthy for (17). Even when he is healthy, he’s usually a non-factor. Just six sacks in two seasons. He’s now a backup.

2a. Jerel Worthy — Missed as many games as he played in (16). While a number of those missed contests were because of injury, others were just because he sucked. Fifteen tackles and 2.5 sacks in two seasons. Shipped out to the Pats this week.

2b. Casey Hayward — Hayward has actually only been healthy for 19 total games after missing most of last season with a hamstring injury. Do you sense a pattern here? Obviously, the Packers were targeting either guys who were dog shit or would be injury-prone for their entire NFL careers. In some cases, they amazingly got both in one guy. Hayward isn’t one of those guys though. He was a playmaker as a rookie and figures to be one again this year.

4a. Mike Daniels — The Packers didn’t get much from Daniels as a rookie, but he came on strong in 2013, with those 6.5 sacks. That was as a backup. Now he’s a starter and we’re looking for him to continue to improve.

4b. Jerron McMillian — Oh. My. God. This sums up McMillian. Safety was the Packers worst position last year. McMillian, a safety, was cut during the season. You don’t hear of many fourth-round picks who don’t make it two season with the team that drafted them.

5. Terrell Manning — Played in just five games as a rookie, which was his only season in Green Bay. Manning was cut prior to the 2013 season.

7a. Andrew Datko — Couldn’t make the Packers as a rookie, but spent the season on the practice squad. Couldn’t make the Packers his second year and it looks like that was the end of his football career.

7b. B.J. Coleman — Coleman took the same route as Datko. One season on the practice squad. The next, out of the NFL.

Two years after drafting eight guys, six of whom were defenders, only three of those guys are still with the Packers. One of them obviously isn’t going to amount to much, so Big Ted is batting a not very impressive .250 for the 2012 draft.

DRAFT AND DEVELOP! Only works when you can, you know, pick guys that can actually play.

Monty McMahon

Monty McMahon is one of the founders of Total Packers. He is probably the most famous graduate of UW-Oshkosh next to Jim Gantner.



  1. Deepsky August 14, 2014

    The 2009 Packer draft was incredible, the 2010 draft was decent. Schneider left in 2010. Dorsey and McKenzie left in 2011. So Thompson spent a lot of time doing the work himself while he trained a bunch of young guys to do the work of 3 long-time Packer draft gurus. The 2011 draft was weaker than the 2012, the 2012 draft was only OK but I think the 2013 draft is looking excellent so far. I think the Packers are back on the right path, but it has taken a while.

    1. geopack August 14, 2014

      Good Cause Chain development. You have your direct, contributing and root causes all identified. Impressive.

      1. [email protected] August 14, 2014

        I would have been even more impressed if it included an idiot proof flow chart, however, I realize how difficult a graphic would be to produce on this site. Additionally, some idiots on this site defy “idiot proof”….

  2. E. Wolf August 14, 2014

    Jason WIlde has pointed out that the 2012 draft overall has been pretty bad. A lot of times these criticisms are just hindsight, such as the case with Jerel Worthy to some extent. Nick Perry though was asked to basically change positions, nevermind just converting schemes. That was the first thing some commentators said when the pick was announced.
    If Perry can somehow turn things around and produce we would still have about 50 percent batting average, which is what you want. Beyond that, both Daniels and Hayward have the real potential to be big time playmakers. All is not lost.

  3. Howard August 14, 2014

    McCarthy after the 2012 season made some statements in press conferences that you could interpret he was not thrilled about the 2012 draft picks. He also made some comments during 2013 that those picks were much better prepared than previous picks ( 2012?). McCarthy will always take the high road, however he has said enough to indicate he was not happy in general with the 2012 drafted players.

  4. Marie August 14, 2014

    Do you ever say anything nice? every article I have read, your kind of a jerk.. what sports have you played?

    1. Chad Lundberg August 14, 2014

      He just says it like it is. It’s not like he’s unfairly criticizing the team, he just gives it to them whenever they deserve it. The 2012 class might be TT’s most disappointing. They’re the ones being paid the big bucks, they ought to produce.

  5. Shawn Neuser August 14, 2014

    How many good players do you think an average draft produces?

    The Packers got at least 2 here with Hayward and Daniels. They might get a third from Perry.

    Look at past drafts as a barometer. 2 impact starters and a possible third is pretty average. Not great, and not terrible either. Just satisfactory. But hard to expect a draft loaded with starters on a 15-1 football team.

  6. Bobby S August 14, 2014

    Not the only draft old gay Ted whiffed on…simple formula, keep Rodgers on the field and ride him to the playoffs. Face the elite and go home