Type to search

Who’s the Odd Man Out in the Green Bay Packers Backfield?

Eddie Lacy

The Green Bay Packers didn’t have to make this decision last year. Unless one of their running backs suffers a season-ending injury during training camp — as DuJuan Harris did in 2013 — they will have to make it this year.

That is, who ends up being the odd man out in a backfield seemingly loaded with quality players?

Let’s assess the cast of characters.

Eddie Lacy
Easy Ed will enter the season as the clear-cut No. 1 on the depth chart, which is something the Packers didn’t have in 2013. After running for 1,178 yards and 11 touchdowns as a rookie, Lacy deserves that designation. Clearly, he’s not going anywhere. Barring injury, the only way Lacy doesn’t get the majority of the carries during the season is if he spends more time in the buffet line than the weight room.

James Starks
Starks was an unrestricted free agent this offseason. We figured, hey, he’s as good as gone. The Packers have enough quality backs without Starks. So of course they went out and gave him a two-year deal for a little over $3 million. The fact that Starks signed it when he could have possibly gotten a larger role elsewhere is as good a sign as any that the Packers told him they plan on using him frequently in 2014. After last season, there’s no reason they shouldn’t. Starks averaged a team high 5.5 yards per carry.

We’re going to assume that if healthy, Lacy and Starks are locks to make the roster. The Packers traditionally keep three running backs and a fullback on their roster. That means this next group of guys will have to fight to make the team. If the traditional total of four backs holds true to form, one of these guys will be released or get traded.

John Kuhn
Yes, we see a real possibility that the Packers could enter a season without Kuhn for the first time since 2006. The veteran has a lot working against him. He’s 31 and guys over 30 are definitely in the minority on the Packers roster. He plays a position that’s all but been eliminated. The Packers are one of the few NFL teams that still use a fullback and even they’ve been utilizing the lead blocker less and less. Like Starks, Kuhn was also a free agent this offseason. Unlike Starks, he didn’t get much of a commitment from the Packers. He took a one-year deal worth just over $1 million, which is a salary reduction. His signing bonus was only $100,000. So the Packers could part with him pretty easily. On the positive side, Kuhn provides veteran leadership and the Packers have very little of that. He’s also extremely valuable on special teams. Then there are the intangibles. You all remember that block on Julius Peppers against the Bears. Ed Lacy doesn’t make that play.

DuJuan Harris
After spending all of last season on injured reserve with a knee injury, Harris is more or less the forgotten man. However, he’s also the guy who entered training camp last year as the No. 1 back (according to Mike McCarthy), the role he earned with his performance late in 2012. So it’s pretty much back to square one for Harris. The good news for him is he’s used to having to battle for a roster spot. Harris went undrafted and was released by the NFL’s junior varsity team, the Jacksonville Jaguars, before joining the Packers. In Green Bay, he worked his way up from the practice squad to the active roster and eventually into a starting role. Unfortunately, that means nothing at this point. Harris is going to have to prove it all over again. He also has the added obstacle of proving he’s fully recovered from his injury.

Johnathan Franklin
Franklin has the undesirable distinction of being another kind of forgotten man. The kind that when game day rolls around, the coaches forget he’s available and he doesn’t get any touches. That happened numerous times in 2013. Franklin wasn’t out of sight, out of mind like Harris. He was literally in sight, but still out of mind. Then he suffered a concussion in late November and the Packers inexplicably put him on injured reserve. None of these things are good signs. Franklin does have two things going for him. In his one chance to be the featured back, Franklin ran for 103 yards against Cincinnati — one of the stronger run defenses in the league — in week three. He was also a fourth-round pick just last season. It will be tough for the Packers to give up on him after only one season, but it seems like a real possibility.

Monty McMahon

Monty McMahon is one of the founders of Total Packers. He is probably the most famous graduate of UW-Oshkosh next to Jim Gantner.



  1. douche baggins June 9, 2014

    its gotta be dujuan. guys a baller and i hope he goes somewhere he is utilized and appreciated. but lacy and starks are guarantees and theyre not getting rid of franklin.

    the REAL question is who do you keep at WR and TE bc you cant have 6 WRs and 4 TEs…

  2. disposable hero June 9, 2014

    I see Franklin getting less reps this year with his neck injury and awful hands. Harris is still a question mark but will likely see a lot of action in preseason so he can be reevaluated. I think the Pack stay with Ed, James, and John.

  3. kato June 9, 2014

    There are going to be a lot of tough decisions on the final roster with the skill position players. This is as competitive as I have seen the skill positions on the packers. I have a bad feeling franklin is the odd man out which is unfortunate

  4. Howard June 9, 2014

    It appears Franklin will be on the PUP list at start of the season. Has Franklin even practiced yet in shorts?

  5. the real russ letlow June 9, 2014

    Franklin’s neck injury could answer the question for us. We are going to cut some quality football players this year at multiple positions. More than I can remember in the last few years. Training camp this year should be real competitive!

  6. Kato June 9, 2014

    Keep in mind if they keep an extra talented running back that also takes away the spot of a young talented receiver or tight end. Quarless is a lock to make the roster because his contract and his seniority among the tight ends. Rodgers will make it because his draft status. After that it gets difficult assuming there arent injuries. Lyerla is a freak, i really hope he keeps the straight and narrow, if so, he should almost be a lock. Bostick is also very talented, but I dont think he beats out any of the aforementioned. Same with Ryan Taylor, although he has been among their best special teamers so he has added value there. If they bring Finley back in the fold that will further complicate things. I dont see them keeping more than 3, maybe 4 tight ends at best with the insane number of young talented prospects at reciever, wouldnt be surprised if they kept six. Not sure a guy like Jeff Janis could be stowed on the practice squad without getting signed by another team.

  7. Shawn Neuser June 9, 2014

    Keep them all. Next question.

  8. 13Time1265 June 9, 2014

    Our backs this year will be Lacy and Harris…Starks has been on and off in the backfield and not as productive. He gave us what we needed in 2011 but that was because of a solid receiver core.

  9. elafave June 10, 2014

    Dude, [email protected], did you even watch The Pack last year???

  10. Lisa June 10, 2014

    This is a fantastic problem to have. Wait…we actually have a running game!! Hallelujah!!!

  11. PackersFan June 11, 2014

    @elafave, Haha, I was wondering the same thing, guess he missed 2013 where Starks was a beast compliment to Lacy. Guess he also missed the fact that Dujuan Harris has actually been non existent really, does he even have 100 yards rushing in Green Bay??

  12. PackersFan June 11, 2014

    @douche bargains, There’s no reason they can’t keep 4 TE’s n 6 WR’s, also keep 4 RB’s n 1 FB. Here’s a logical roster breakdown

    OFFENSE QB-2, RB-5, WR-6, TE-4, OL-8, K-1, P-1, LS-1 28 OFFENSIVE PLAYERS.


    A completely logical 53 man roster breakdown.