Type to search

NFL May Eliminate Pro Bowl: Here’s Our Solution

Aaron Rodgers

NFL commissioner Roger Goodell said Sunday he was disappointed in the quality of the Pro Bowl and the league may consider eliminating the game.

Good riddance. We haven’t watched the Pro Bowl in years because the game itself is a joke. It’s boring and is held at a point in the season when fans just want to see their teams play, but instead get a watered down all-star game while they’re waiting for a Super Bowl matchup they probably don’t care about. It’s also hard to call the Pro Bowl a true all-star game, since the players in the Super Bowl don’t play and seemingly a third of each roster drops out for “injury” or other reasons, only to be replaced by guys who probably have no business being there.

This year’s Pro Bowl was marred by fans in the stands booing the players and Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers chastising teammates for not putting forth any effort.

“We’re either going to have to improve the quality of what we’re doing in the Pro Bowl or consider other changes or even considering eliminating the game if that’s the kind of quality game we’re going to provide,” Goodell said.

“I know players love to be in Hawaii but we have to start with the quality of what we’re doing,” Goodell said. “If the fans are responding negatively to what we’re doing, we better listen. And that was my message.”

So what to do?

Obviously, the game can’t be moved to midseason like the other major sports’ all-star games because of the injury risk. There are players, especially pending free agents, who say they don’t go hard in the Pro Bowl because they’re worried about their next contract and rightfully so. Why risk millions of dollars in a meaningless game?

The problem is, there’s no way to make the Pro Bowl meaningful.

Baseball puts home field advantage in the World Series on the line, but that can’t be done with the Pro Bowl because of when it’s played and the fact the Super Bowl is held, in all probability, on a neutral field.

The NHL has experimented with a North America vs. The World format and, more recently, they’ve let designated captains choose their teams playground-style. Both are interesting concepts, but the first one wouldn’t work for the Pro Bowl because the NFL has hardly any foreign players. The second might make the game more interesting, but it isn’t going to stop anyone from dropping out or mailing it in.

The NBA All-Star Game is the closest thing to the Pro Bowl. No one plays any defense, but people love the NBA All-Star Game because all the biggest stars actually play and the fans get to see what they want — a run-and-gun dunk fest.

So what to do with the Pro Bowl?

We don’t see any way to salvage it, so get rid of it. The NFL should still elect Pro Bowlers as they do now by letting fans, players and coaches vote, but they don’t need to play the game.

Frankly, the most exciting part of the Pro Bowl is seeing who’s on the rosters. We tune out after that. So pick the Pro Bowlers and let it be an honor like making the All-Pro team. That way guys don’t need to worry about getting injured, the league doesn’t need to worry about players not giving effort and how the fans feel and the fans don’t have to worry about wasting time on some watered-down product featuring a bunch of guys who didn’t deserve to be there to begin with.

The league can easily move their new awards show, which was held for the first time Saturday night, up a weekend to fill the time. It will probably even be more popular. Who doesn’t like to see people get awards and watch highlights?

It’s sure as hell a more appealing option than watching the Pro Bowl.

Monty McMahon

Monty McMahon is one of the founders of Total Packers. He is probably the most famous graduate of UW-Oshkosh next to Jim Gantner.



  1. Kevin February 5, 2012

    What are your thoughts about replacing the game with a series of contests like most accurate passer from various yardages, etc.?

  2. Ed Gein February 5, 2012

    Yeah, some kind of skills competition like the slamdunk contest, or homerun derby. Maybe sumu wrestling for the line men.

  3. peter February 5, 2012

    yeah skill comp would be killer I love watching that stuff.

  4. tkhelland February 6, 2012

    I read a post on another website were a guy went in to detail on a skills competition and it sounded awesome. He made it sound almost like a combine for the pros. Not only would it be fun to watch but just think how it would help (or hurt) the up coming free agent class. I think ultimately it would be entertaining and help the league I’m sick of watching players half ass it on the field the linemen looked like beached whales and everyone else gave 10% get rid of it already.

  5. Kozak February 6, 2012

    Take it one step further . Select the pro bowl team, then simulate it in Madden.