Type to search

Predictions: Packers vs. Giants

Justin Tuck

Justin Tuck does more than just Subway commercials.

Steffen: Many are expecting the New York Giants to fall apart this week after a humiliating defeat at the hands of Michael Vick and the Philadelphia Eagles in week 15. I don’t see it playing out that way. The Giants are a veteran team and they have a lot to play for.

This is essentially a playoff game for both teams and I think it’s much more likely the Packers and Giants will make it a close game, which could spell trouble for Green Bay.

If there was ever a moral victory for Green Bay, it happened last week against the New England Patriots. Minus Aaron Rodgers, the Packers far exceded expectations. Led by the more poised and accurate than advertised Matt Flynn, the Packers unleashed a balanced offensive attack and dominated the heavily favored Patriots, one of the best teams in the league.

In the end, they were undone by poor clock management and (again) special teams breakdowns. These areas absolutely have to improve if Green Bay expects to do anything in the playoffs.

Aaron Rodgers must feel some pressure has been lifted off his shoulders. Against the Patriots, his teammates proved they can compete without him. I think this will allow him to settle into the offense and trust his teammates to make plays.

As I mentioned, this will be another close game, but the Pack will have their eyes on the prize and will finally emerge victorious in another game decided by four points or less.

Packers 33, Giants 31

Shawn: For a regular season game, it doesn’t get any bigger than this. I believe both of these teams are among the five best teams in the NFC, and both are capable of making the Super Bowl if they go on a roll in the playoffs. However, only one team will likely make the playoffs, and it will be decided by this game.

Offense — wash. If this game was in a dome, then the edge would go to the Packers’ offense, but with it being played on grass, outdoors, in 20-degree weather, it’s a tie at best for the Packers. The Giants clearly have the better running game, and they love to attack the edge, which is where the Packers have been soft all season. However, I believe the Packers’ running game can be a factor. The Giants’ defensive line loves to get up field, and Brandon Jackson is an ideal back to attack that. The big variables here are Aaron Rodgers, coming off an inactive week, and the Giants’ wide receivers. It’s a totally different unit than the one that excelled in the cold at Lambeau in the 2007 NFC Championship game. The receivers who best overcomes the conditions might make the difference in the game.

Defense — Packers. This is a close one, but I have to give the Packer defense the edge. The conditions and the field will help slow the Giants’ pass rush, which is their greatest weapon. The Packers D is better in the secondary, and if both teams struggle to get to the quarterback, it will be a big advantage for the Packers. The difference may very well be the Pack’s run defense at the edges. The Giants can control the game if they can consistently run it. Charles Woodson will be key in stopping the outside runs. The Packers need a big-time game from him. Lastly, the Packers absolutely have to get turnovers when opportunities present themselves. Eli Manning was excellent through three quarters against Philly, but is prone to throwing picks. The Packers need to catch the ball if it’s thrown their way.

Special teams — wash. Believe it or not, the Giants are about as bad on special teams as the Packers. The Giants, like everyone else, are better than the Packers in coverage, but the Packers have better returners. The kicking battle is pretty much even. The Giants have been iffy at kicker most of the season, and their punter is a rookie who is unlikely to have faced the conditions in Lambeau.

Intangibles — Packers. A lot of people want to give the Giants the edge here because they should be angry after their collapse last week. That anger, however, can work against them. The Giants certainly should be fired up at the start of the game and being on the road will actually help that “us versus the world” mentality the Giants seem to thrive on, but the memory of the collapse has to lurk in their minds and erode their confidence. In other words, if the Packers can get ahead and lean on the Giants, they might fall apart like they did at the end of last season. Also, it might be harder for the Giants offense to remain patient, even with a lead, remembering how big of a lead they gave up last week.

The Packers have lost two consecutive close road games and are back home with their starting QB back. They certainly feel they’re one of the better teams in the league, but know all the talk is meaningless if they lose this game and miss the playoffs. The Packers will be just as ready for this game as the Giants.

Experience goes to the Giants.

The two biggest intangibles in this game go to the Packers. One is home field advantage. Yes, Eli Manning and the Giants have already proven they can play well at Lambeau in the cold. However, playing at home usually gives the home team a break or two, and that could make a huge difference in this game. Lastly, there’s the fact the Packers HAVE to win this game. Lose, and they are out of the playoffs. The Giants could still make the playoffs if they win in week 17 and the Packers lose to the Bears. Yes, the Giants would certainly prefer to seal the deal by winning this game, but they don’t absolutely HAVE to win, and that has to make a difference.

This is a tough, tough game. Packers by 10 if they had Grant, Finley and Jenkins, but all three are out. Nick Collins is beat up and Frank Zombo is out. How many injuries can this team overcome? Frankly, they’re probably too injured to win this game against a top NFC team, but they are at home and it is the biggest game in Rodgers’ career. Somehow, I have to believe the Packers will get it done.

Packers 27, Giants 24

Sarah: The stakes couldn’t be higher in this game, and the Giants are dangerous coming off an epic collapse last weekend against the Philadelphia Eagles.

New York can clinch an NFC Wild Card berth with a win, while the Packers must win to keep their playoff hopes alive.

“(The stakes are) clear as a bell,” Giants coach Tom Coughlin said. “In this day and age, everyone is aware of exactly what is at stake, so it’s very honest and very straightforward to express that and make players aware of it.”

This is what December football should be, and Sunday’s contest at Lambeau promises not to disappoint.

While Matt Flynn filled in admirably against the Patriots, Green Bay is breathing a sigh of relief to get starting quarterback Aaron Rodgers back following his second concussion of the season.

He’ll be the key to dicing up the Giants’ secondary and getting Green Bay’s offense on track.

Both teams are stellar on defense, ranking first and second in the NFC in sacks, with 42 by New York and 40 by Green Bay. Packers linebacker Clay Matthews leads the conference with 12.5, while the Giants’ Justin Tuck and Osi Umenyiora are the only teammates with 10 apiece.

This is the first meeting between these teams since New York won 23-20 in overtime at Lambeau three seasons ago in the NFC championship, Brett Favre’s final game with the Packers.

The Packers have won nine of their last 10 at home. All six of their losses have been by four points or fewer.

This is going to be another great game, and I think this time, we’ll prevail.

Packers 20, Giants 14

Monty: Mike McCarthy is a great offensive coordinator. He’s not much of a head coach, though.

I have nightmares of him getting outcoached by the Giants Tom Coughlin in the 2007 NFC Championship game. Fortunately, the Packers don’t have some interception-tossing douche playing quarterback this time around.

Aaron Rodgers and Charles Woodson will not let the Packers lose this game, even though McCarthy will do his best to fuck it up.

Packers 24, Giants 20

Monty McMahon

Monty McMahon is one of the founders of Total Packers. He is probably the most famous graduate of UW-Oshkosh next to Jim Gantner.



  1. ay hombre December 25, 2010

    I hate to say it, but I don’t like how we match up. Giants run the ball and control the 2nd half and outscore us by 2 TD’S in the 4th quarter. Packers 23 Giants 31

  2. Richard December 25, 2010

    The team, led by McCarthy, seemed thrilled to ‘only’ lose by 4 last week. I’m guessing they’ll play for another moral victory in this one too and be happy to finish with a non-losing record while the Giants shoot for a playoff run. NYG 23-20. Again.

  3. nurseratchett December 25, 2010


    Come on Pack, win a big one for the home crowd.

    Packers 24 Giants 21

  4. Killa December 25, 2010

    I’ve been to 4 Packer home games. They are 4-0 when I attend. I plan on keeping up this trend when I attend sunday. If Packers focus on slowing down the run game, and make Eli beat them through the air Tramon and Charles could have big days.
    Packers win on a 4th quarter defensive stand.
    Packers 27 Gayants 23

  5. Go Packers! December 25, 2010

    It is gonna be a defensive stand. Depending on how our secondary is and also our DL if they can hold Jacobs and Bradshaw. Maybe the packers can have a good running game like they did last week. The packers pull it out GB 27 NYG 24

  6. Cody December 25, 2010

    Hey ay hombre and Richard, when you two are done scissoring each other you can come talk some football. How do you pussy’s call yourself Packers fans?? Always gotta hope for the best even if McLardo starts thinking about a ‘Big ‘n Tasty’ during the final two minutes of the game again. The Pack are mad, I can sense it…A-Rod doesn’t even give ST the chance to fuck this one up for us.
    Pack 38
    Giants 17

    1. nurseratchett December 26, 2010

      CODY IS THE MAN!!!!!!!! Nice call, dude!

  7. ay hombre December 25, 2010

    Cody…man I hope you’re right. I’d love to be wrong.

    1. nurseratchett December 26, 2010

      THAT’S WHAT I’M TALKING ABOUT! I’m with you Cody!! GO PACK GO!!!!!

  8. Justin December 25, 2010

    Packers shutout the new York midgets just like they did the jets and remind the league who they are fuckin with.

  9. Andy December 26, 2010

    Well cody you actually have a good point. I hope it is that big of a blowout. It will hopefully happen.

  10. Randomacity December 26, 2010

    Packers aren’t gonna win, we’ll either keep it close and choke, or be winning and then choke. Basically the same game as the Falcons but with more time, or a lot like the Pats game.

    Packers 24
    Giants 28

  11. Justin December 26, 2010

    You call yourself fans? We are gonna win, I don’t know what’s up with this lack of faith in the green and gold but it disgusts me. Pack will win there next six games and bring home the bacon.

  12. Cade Lawson December 26, 2010

    Packers 28 Giants 21

  13. Andy December 26, 2010

    Cody you were right!

  14. Madcity Packer Fan December 26, 2010

    Steffen now it will be unlucky for you to pick against the Packers.

  15. Flyboy December 26, 2010

    Close game? Wow, was that prediction off or what?????

  16. Andy December 26, 2010

    Cody dude do you know stuff we don’t know? Lol

  17. Cody December 26, 2010

    Ha thanks for all the support guys! Just really felt confident about the guys going into that game…I really think McCarthy was still bitter from that loss from ’07 so I didn’t see him letting up at all. Rodgers could have had 2 more TD’s if Jones would pull his head out of his ass on those easy catches.
    Gotta love that win…now we just gotta crush those douchebag Bears next week!

  18. ay hombre December 26, 2010

    Unbelievable win and Aaron Rodgers best game to date. Reason why? Amazing protection all day long. If our offensive line can play like that next week, we’ll tear up the Bears the same way, even though it appears the Bears are not afraid of a shootout either.

    Although I’ve been hard on MM, which I stand by, he seems to be pulling his head out of his ass and is showing some dedication to the run regardless if it’s working. The way we came out running the ball teamed with our previous success versus the Patriots on shotgun draw plays, was a direct result of Jordy Nelson’s 80 yard touchdown.

    MM called a great game and FINISHED them. That’s how we need to win games from now on, so clock management isn’t even a concern. Just blow em out.

    The Bears have a lot to play for and sure as hell don’t want to be facing the Packers in the playoffs so expect them to bring it full throttle. But my game ball certainly goes to the O-line and Aaron for a nearly flawless day. If our O-line plays like that, we can outscore anyone. Hell I’ll even give MM a game ball…he deserves one.