Frank Winters is No Student of NFL History
Frank Winters must have gotten hit in the head one too many times. The former Green Bay Packers center says Brett Favre is one of the five best players of all time.
“In my opinion, he was probably one of the top five players to ever play the game. He was a special person, special individual, and hopefully they can get this thing worked out here in the upcoming months and get him back to Green Bay where he deserves to go into the Hall of Fame and to the NFL Hall of Fame,” Winters told the Marshview Conservation Club’s annual dinner banquet, on Tuesday.
Now, let’s analyze the shit out of this because why the hell not?
No. 1, Brett Favre is not even the best player in Green Bay Packers history. Don Hutson — far and away.
No. 2, I would make the argument that Favre is not even the best quarterback in Packers history. Bart Starr and his five championships get that nod, although there’s probably a more lively debate to be had there.
Even if Favre is the best quarterback in Packers history, most sane people would argue that Favre is not the best quarterback in NFL history. I give that nod to Joe Montana. Life or death situation, one drive, have to score — you sure as hell don’t want Brett Favre leading that charge. You want Joe Montana.
Then there are the old timers who like to back Johnny Unitas as the best quarterback ever. I never saw him play, but I do know he chucked a ton of interceptions, so I’m sticking with Montana.
In any case, let’s say Favre is the third best quarterback of all time, which he probably isn’t. Then, let’s say the Packers somehow have two of the five greatest players of all time, which is impossible because Hutson would come in second in the receiver category behind Jerry Rice. However, in this totally impossible scenario Favre comes in at fifth on the list of greatest players of all time.
Of course, you’d have to completely ignore any other position to achieve that. You know, get rid of running backs like Jim Brown and Barry Sanders. Forget about anyone on defense, like, say, Reggie White.
So, yeah, in other words, Frank Winters made a totally moronic statement. But that’s probably to be expected. Winters spent 10 seasons snapping the ball to Favre and the two were pretty much inseparable off the field.
Besides, the guy’s nickname is Old Bag of Donuts. It’s not The Professor.
Monty McMahon is one of the founders of Total Packers. He is probably the most famous graduate of UW-Oshkosh next to Jim Gantner.